Welcome to our ELL 1 blog!

This purpose of this blog is for you to interact with me and with each other on a regular basis --- in a safe, protected environment. I will post prompts and questions and you will need to respond by the deadline. Please read and comment on the posts of your classmates and ask questions of each other.

For all journal entries, please think deeply about the question and write a thoughtful (not too short!) response. You do not have to have perfect grammar but be sure to have a subject & verb in each sentence, and be sure that each sentence make sense. Through writing, your language skills and will improve, andeach one one of you will grow as a person.

Tuesday, April 23, 2013

Forgive and/or Punish? - due Friday, MAY 3

Recently, two bombs exploded in Boston, killing 3 and injuring many. The two suspects were identified fairly quickly, and one of the boys has just been arrested. In your opinion, what should happen next? Should he be forgiven?  Do you think he should be punished?  If it were your decision, what punishment would you give?  If this event had occurred in your home country, what punishment would the leaders of your country give?

14 comments:

  1. I think he should be forgiven, if not he'll accumulate more hatred. Besides he should be punished , so that he could remember his defect. I think he is support to stay in prison, and do a lot of work , help him be eager and be nicer to people. Gradually, people thank him, he can feel the love and be thankful to people. In my country, I think the punishment is too cruel.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think we should give the young boy life imprisonment, although he put two bound in Boston and exploded. If these thing happen in our country we will feel insecurity. I think they will kill them or let them life imprisonment.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think that they should be punished. Because they disturbed people and killed some of them.If it will be my opinion i will kill them and show it on the all TV chanels to show what i will do if someone will do something like that. If this event had occurred in my country i think he will be punished like killed by gun.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think he should be forgiven. Because punishment can't make him be nice to the people, it can make him mad at people and do something against people again. We should teach him how to be a nice person. For example, we can encourage him to do something good for people. Gradually, he will like helping the people and become an useful person for the community. If this event had occurred in my country, the government would punish the suspects hard.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This is a difficult question. He killed and hurt a lot of people. These thing is really bad, so he need to be punished.The degree of the punishment is depend on why did he do that.If he just hate the country, I think he need to be die because he is a inhumanity person.He made a lot of family's heart break,and he has to pay that.Another way, if he hate the social because he ever lost something important for him and the social gave him a unfair answer, so he did that.If this is the true, I think we can decrease the punishment. Everybody all have something really important,and we all know how sad if we lose them. The boy is a human, too.Maybe he just lost his mind at that moment,so I think maybe he need to stay at jail for a long time and also he need a doctor to fix his sick from his heart.This is my opinion.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think he be forgiven,because they other boy,then we kill he,that makes 2 more people to die,then we can change him to make him to a good people,can good at community

    ReplyDelete
  7. I think If i am a leader I think he should be punished, because they hurt many people and three people are died. If it were your decision, I can confine he to when he died. In my country all people can't buy bomb, so In china can't happen about bomb or gun.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I think If i were a judge, I would punish him by putting him. In prison until he died because he hurt many people and three people died. This is my opinion. In my country people can't buy bombs or guns. This would not happen In China.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I think it should be forgiven because even the people can remember them, what can people do? So I think if i am a jungle i will put them to the prison until they can tell the polices who let them do it. If this things will happen in my country. The government will let them die. Of course that kind of things will be happen again but who can stop it? Nobody knows.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I think it should't be forgiven because he kill people.And he hurt that people and they family.If I decision he will have procession on the street and die.If in my country he will die also.And that things will happen again.And after long time people will forget that.But the family of the deceased will remember that forever.

    ReplyDelete
  11. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I think he should not be forgiven because he hurts a lot of people and he kills three people. I think he should be punished. He lets a lot of people were injured, many people cried and destroyed others family. I think he should go to jail or sentenced to death because he is really a bad guy. If in China I think he should be sentenced to death. Maybe long time after people forget this person, but we will remember this event have occurred.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I think he was punished by the country. Because he with his companion killed 3 people and abundant people were hurt by them. So I think he must in the prison in his future. If Boston's terrorist attack in the China. He maybe was killed by government.

    ReplyDelete
  14. i think he was punished by the country. Two men killed 3 people and hurt many people. So i think he must died.
    A chinese girl died in the accident. So i think they must be died. we can not give them change again to hurt people, and distory other families. we also need waring other people.

    ReplyDelete