New York Times article, 10/16/11: Protesting in public spaces
slide show of protests around the globe
You may not yet know the English words, "protest" and "occupy," but they are good words to know because they can be heard regularly on the news - all around the world. This week's journal is about protesting. Do you think it is effective for a large number of people to come together in a public space and ask for change through occupation, signs, chants, and sometimes more physical action? Do you think the people have a right to that space or does the space belong to the government? Do you think the message of a group of people, such as in NYC or other cities, can make a difference? Feel free to give examples of protests that have taken place in your home country.
Welcome to our ELL 1 blog!
This purpose of this blog is for you to interact with me and with each other on a regular basis --- in a safe, protected environment. I will post prompts and questions and you will need to respond by the deadline. Please read and comment on the posts of your classmates and ask questions of each other.
For all journal entries, please think deeply about the question and write a thoughtful (not too short!) response. You do not have to have perfect grammar but be sure to have a subject & verb in each sentence, and be sure that each sentence make sense. Through writing, your language skills and will improve, andeach one one of you will grow as a person.
For all journal entries, please think deeply about the question and write a thoughtful (not too short!) response. You do not have to have perfect grammar but be sure to have a subject & verb in each sentence, and be sure that each sentence make sense. Through writing, your language skills and will improve, andeach one one of you will grow as a person.

This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI think sometimes it is nice when the people work together. If these people want to work together and have a plan like a change world then it's a good idea. Sometimes government disagree but it's very interesting when government agree. I think peoples do it because they are need a money or something else or the prices in markets are very huge. More people do a protest in their works because they want more money. People on Slovakia are good but sometimes we are have some protest like when the teachers are want a bigger payment or people who works in hospital. I have a protest with myself now because i want to stay in cafeteria when i have study hall because i now my english is not very good but i think the other kids can help me sometimes with my homeworks and it will be better for me because i need a lot of talking in English language and if i will stay in cafeteria it will be better for my English skills because i will be talk a lot with Syed and Carly and the other kids. Thank you for thinking one more about it Filip
ReplyDeleteI'm sorry, protest this activity, in China a party in the country of the sanctions, it is very difficult to large-scale activities, therefore, protests in China is very rare.
ReplyDeletein my opinion, i think that people are protesting is because if their country can not give them a good living environment.like government is unfair, people always keep a brand that write something on it.like they write Reduce co2 emissions,let people dont drive the car,the best example is financial crisis,many persons lost their work,and they even have no money to living in the world.everyone has power that is free.i think be a government,should work for us,let people live in a good environment, is not let them lose a work or cant still live in the world.
ReplyDeleteHi! I know what "protest" means and in my opinion it makes our life difficult but usually protests help people show their dissatisfaction an anger over a certain matter, which they think it can be better to make their life more comfortable but sometimes it does not help because people can't influence their government, and those who are in the leadership. I have never seen any protests in real life only on the TV and I have never taken part in protests but I would like to try it because I want to know what you will feel when you make it. Who makes protests does a great deal of mistakes because it doesn't matter who are you I mean woman or man you can be decry, also you can be injured because policemen usually use their guns. I read Alexander's story and i do not agree with him because in Russia we have not protests because people afraid of showing their dissatisfaction but I do not know-WHY. Maybe it is because there are not enough people who can make protests. In Russia everybody agrees with leadership. There are people who don't want to drift through life in my country and make protests because they want to get more money and in their opinion government wastes money not for improving the country or city. Also in my country poor people hate person who has a lot of money. I agree with these people and also I hate when somebody who is in the leadership make promises but nobody does not do it. There is one of the most important problem is shy people and it is difficult to make protest when you are scared. I like people who can show their dissatisfaction. In the end I want to say that people need to make protests because it is important for future life and also you should be politely with leadership because sometimes people who are in the government do something good for our life.
ReplyDeleteI think the protesting for the policy of government always doesn't work,because government will consider what will the other country think about china,and is that good for the whole country.Sometimes the policy from government will affects the benefits of some people,then they will protest.But China is a big country with 1.3billion people.The government is not able to make sure every family can get benefits from the policy.People can't understand the government or because the policy influence them,they will protesting.But it doesn't work,because government consider about the benefits of whole country,they won't change the policy for a small part of Chinese.And if the protesting is about a policy from the local government like Municipal government,maybe the protesting will be work.And I think we shouldn't protesting if we know it's not too possible to achieve.Because protesting will will waste your time and energy if you know it's not too possible to achieve.And I think revolution is more likely to change government minds.So I think we should not waste time on the thing we can't change.We can protesting for something small,that is possible to change.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI think it is effective for a large number of people because a lot of people have a right to that space . Many protests and occupies have asked for a change through more physical action.I think protests and occupies such as in NYC or other cities, can make a difference because cities and countries have many people .Government a not major for people.i don't like protests and occupies. i have never had this. i have a friend in Russia , he likes a protests .In Russia we have many protests and occupies. It's bad for Russia. A lot of occupies asked for a change through physical action. And people like it but sometime we have protests asked for a change through signs and chants.In Moscow we had a protest.several hundred scientists staged a protest and demanded more control over their work.they said"We need to liberate our scientists".
ReplyDeleteI think a lot of people have a right to that space
First at all,I wanna say it will become a very big problem even influence people life if it can not stop in the end.Up to now,you can see,less people are very rich but a lot of people in the world are very poor.it is a unfair thing,so people did the protesting and occupy in many countries.In my view,on the one hand I think it is a good thing,now somebody was very rich in the world,they had a wonderful lifestyle everyday and someone waste money everyday but someone was very poor they do not have money even cannot eat meals everyday,it made them felt uncomfortable and upset they did protesting and occupy can make government plan to do some stratagems to reduce the disparity and help those poor people.For example,increase the tax it can make the rich person take out more money.On the other hand,I think it is not a good thing,people did protesting and occupy also made the disturbance,like I saw the same thing in the Boston last week,they had two more hundred people,they appealed person to join them and made the heavy traffic also made big noisy,I think it is not good for everyone.In brief,I believe the thing will have a good ending in the end.
ReplyDeleteIn China, I never see any protest. I have seen protest on TV. It is very pageantry. Everyone hold up a sign that states what they want. In my opinion, our world needs protest, because government and the masses need a way to exchange. At the same time, I think we don’t need too much protest, because equity and human rights. Such as if some people don’t have jobs. The government will give them money, but it isn’t equity. So I don’t think protest is useful.
ReplyDelete